MyExtraCards was founded by Steve O’Day, who has been collecting sports trading cards for decades. In the 1980’s, Steve started selling sports trading cards out of his basement and his personal collection has continued to expand. Over the past ten years, Steve has brought in his two sons, Josh and Jason, as fellow collectors and business partners to help MyExtraCards continue to grow. Today, we have the goal of building the premier destination for sports trading card enthusiasts across the United States.

MyExtraCards is more of a hobby than a business. It is owned and operated by three sports trading card enthusiasts who also continue to build their own personal collections. We understand the rush that is experienced when opening a new box in hopes of it containing a valuable card, and the excitement when you get the card you’ve been looking for. We know what it is like to build a collection of cards for your favorite sport or player, and how you can become personally attached to your favorites. This is a hobby we are passionate about, and we look forward to sharing our enthusiasm with other collectors.

MyExtraCards serves both experienced and beginner collectors, and everyone in between. We have millions of single sports trading cards available, from high value cards to single cards you may be searching for to complete a set. We also offer a variety of hobby boxes for every major sport. In addition, we are able to provide supplies such as soft and hard sleeves, cases and boxes so our customers can safely and securely store their own personal collections. Our goal is to be a one-stop destination for all of your sports trading card collecting needs.

MyExtraCards takes pride in serving our customers. As fellow collectors, we want to ensure you receive 5-star service during every step of the process when you purchase an item from our store. Our website is highly secure and safe. We offer free, fast shipping on most of our items, and we take great care in our packaging to ensure your item arrives safe and undamaged. We’re also available for any questions you may have. We have too many items to list on our website, so if there is a specific card or hobby box you are searching for please don’t hesitate to contact us. We will always do everything in our power to help our fellow collectors!

    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop

    Thank You!

    Please Consider Leaving
    Us 5-Star Review

    Sorry to hear we're not meeting your expectations

    Please enter your feedback below:

    Do you recommend MyExtraCards?